Sarah had been replaying The Witcher 3 for the fifth time when the rumors started spreading like wildfire across Reddit and Discord servers. After hundreds of hours exploring Novigrad’s crowded streets and the windswept isles of Skellige, she thought she knew everything about Geralt’s world. Then whispers of a surprise 2026 DLC expansion began circulating, and suddenly her favorite game felt fresh with possibility again.
But as Sarah scrolled through heated forum debates, she realized this wasn’t just excitement brewing in the community. Players were genuinely divided about who should star in this mysterious new content. Some demanded more time with the gruff, silver-haired witcher they’d grown to love. Others argued it was time to fully embrace Ciri as the series’ new protagonist, especially with The Witcher 4 on the horizon.
The division runs deeper than simple character preference. It reflects a fundamental question about what The Witcher franchise should become as it evolves beyond Geralt’s story.
What We Know About the Rumored Witcher 3 DLC
The potential Witcher 3 DLC has emerged from industry speculation and insider hints rather than official announcements from CD Projekt Red. Current rumors suggest the expansion would bridge the narrative gap between The Witcher 3’s conclusion and the upcoming fourth installment.
This timing makes the protagonist choice particularly crucial. The expansion could serve as either a final farewell to Geralt or an extended introduction to Ciri’s expanded role in the series. Industry analyst Marcus Chen notes, “The character choice here isn’t just about fan service. It’s about establishing the franchise’s future direction.”
The rumored DLC would likely explore events that occurred during the years between games, potentially showing how Ciri developed into the seasoned witcher we’ll meet in The Witcher 4. However, many fans argue that Geralt’s story deserves a more substantial conclusion than what the base game provided.
Breaking Down the Fan Divide
The community split over the DLC’s protagonist reveals fascinating insights about player attachment and franchise expectations. Here’s what both sides are arguing:
| Team Geralt | Team Ciri |
|---|---|
| Geralt deserves a proper sendoff | Time to embrace the new generation |
| His gameplay mechanics are refined | Fresh combat abilities and magic |
| Emotional connection spans three games | Better preparation for Witcher 4 |
| Proven narrative appeal | Untapped storytelling potential |
Long-time series fan and content creator Elena Rodriguez explains, “Geralt has been our window into this world for over a decade. Many players aren’t ready to let go of that connection, especially in what might be his final adventure.”
Conversely, newer players often express excitement about Ciri’s possibilities. Her unique Elder Blood abilities and teleportation powers could introduce gameplay mechanics that feel genuinely fresh after years of traditional witcher combat.
The debate also touches on broader themes about legacy and change in gaming franchises. Some players view clinging to Geralt as resistance to natural evolution, while others see it as honoring the character who made the series beloved.
Why This Choice Matters Beyond Gaming
The protagonist decision carries implications that extend well beyond a single DLC expansion. CD Projekt Red faces the challenge of transitioning one of gaming’s most beloved characters while maintaining the series’ core identity.
Game narrative designer Jake Morrison observes, “This isn’t just about who players control. It’s about whether the franchise can successfully pivot to a new protagonist while preserving what made the original trilogy special.”
The choice also reflects changing expectations in gaming. Modern players often prefer fresh experiences over retreading familiar ground, yet they also value emotional continuity with established characters. The Witcher 3 DLC protagonist decision must balance these competing desires.
For CD Projekt Red, the stakes are particularly high following the challenging launch of Cyberpunk 2077. The studio needs this expansion to reinforce confidence in their ability to deliver quality content while setting up The Witcher 4’s success.
Marketing considerations also play a role. Featuring Geralt could drive higher sales among existing fans, while starring Ciri might attract newcomers curious about the series’ future direction. The decision ultimately shapes how the gaming community perceives the franchise’s commitment to evolution versus tradition.
Some industry observers suggest a compromise approach might be possible, featuring both characters in different sections or allowing players to choose their protagonist. However, such solutions often dilute the narrative focus that makes single-character stories compelling.
The fan division also highlights how deeply players connect with video game protagonists compared to other media. Unlike movies or books, games create active relationships between players and characters through hundreds of hours of shared experiences. Changing protagonists feels more personal when you’ve directly controlled their actions and decisions.
FAQs
When will The Witcher 3 DLC be officially announced?
CD Projekt Red hasn’t confirmed any new Witcher 3 content, though rumors suggest an announcement could come in 2026.
Could the DLC feature both Geralt and Ciri as playable characters?
While possible, most expansions focus on a single protagonist to maintain narrative coherence and development resources.
Will this DLC be required to understand The Witcher 4?
Based on typical franchise practices, the DLC would likely enhance but not be essential for understanding the sequel’s story.
How long would this rumored expansion be?
If following the pattern of previous Witcher 3 expansions, expect 15-30 hours of additional content.
Why are fans so divided about the protagonist choice?
Players have deep emotional connections to Geralt after three games, while others are excited about Ciri’s fresh possibilities and role in the series’ future.
What makes this protagonist decision so important for the franchise?
The choice signals CD Projekt Red’s approach to transitioning between gaming generations while maintaining series identity and fan loyalty.
About the Author
