Target, one of America’s leading retail giants, is once again at the center of controversy. A recent shift in the company’s store operations policy has sparked an outcry from shoppers nationwide. The retailer, known for its sleek aisles and well-organized shelves, has introduced a change that, while seemingly operational, directly impacts in-store shopping experiences—and some customers aren’t pleased.
The backlash stems from newly implemented restrictions surrounding self-checkout services. While Target insists this is an effort to improve the customer experience and reduce theft, long-time patrons argue that it leads to longer wait times, decreased autonomy for shoppers, and a more frustrating visit overall. As debates rage on social media and concerned consumers voice their dissatisfaction, it raises larger questions about how retailers are balancing security, staffing, and shopper satisfaction in a changing economic landscape.
Target’s New Checkout Policy Overview
| Policy Change | Limited self-checkout access for smaller purchases only |
|---|---|
| Purchase Limit | 10 items or fewer to use self-checkout at select stores |
| Primary Complaint | Longer waits at full-service checkout lanes |
| Purpose of Change | Improve customer flow and reduce shrink (loss due to theft/error) |
| Impacted Locations | Varies by region, pilot testing at major city stores |
| Public Response | Mixed—some support, many frustrated |
What changed with the self-checkout policy
Target has begun implementing a self-checkout cap at select locations, limiting shoppers to using these lanes only for purchases totaling ten items or fewer. Previously, customers could use the self-checkout regardless of how many items they had, lending speed and discretion to their shopping experience. The retailer now says the change is part of broader improvements to promote smooth and efficient interactions at checkout stations.
For shopping parties doing larger grocery runs or seasonal buying—a common scenario at Target—this policy pushes them toward full-service lanes manned by cashiers. And as many stores have reduced staffing to align with labor costs, that has translated to longer wait times with fewer available cashiers. Online, shoppers vent their frustration, citing inconvenience and perceived regression in efficient service.
Why Target made the change
Target has been tight-lipped about the specifics, but retail experts point toward two major motivations: enhancing customer satisfaction and reducing store shrink. Store shrink, the industry term for inventory loss due to theft, operational error, or damage, has been steadily increasing across the industry. Self-checkout stations, while convenient, are often targeted by shoplifters due to the ease of scanning errors or skipped items.
By limiting self-checkout to smaller transactions, Target reduces the chances of high-value or bulk theft incidents being missed. Additionally, it provides an opportunity for store associates to better monitor activity and assist customers more personally. According to Target spokespeople, this move has already resulted in positive performance in test markets.
“Retail shrink is a very real and growing problem, and retailers are forced to rethink technology to mitigate losses.”
— Jane Rowland, Retail Strategy ConsultantAlso Read
Rosa Parks Day: Which states officially observe it, and is it a federal holiday?
Who wins and who loses under the new checkout policy
| Winners | Losers |
|---|---|
| Small-basket shoppers looking for swift checkout | Bulk buyers, families, and shoppers with large carts |
| Store operations aiming to reduce loss | Customers with accessibility concerns preferring self-checkout |
| Cashier workload potentially more stable | High-efficiency shoppers preferring quick in-and-out |
Customer reaction has been swift and divided
Social media platforms have been flooded with opinions from shoppers across all demographics. Some praise the new policy, saying that it reduces chaos at checkout and adds a layer of human oversight that helps customers and reduces fraud. Others are far less forgiving. Frequent Target shoppers have voiced concern about longer lines, particularly during weekends and holidays, when high volumes mean traditional checkout points are easily overwhelmed.
One sentiment repeatedly echoed is confusion over why the choice is being taken out of the hands of the consumer. For many, the convenience and speed of self-checkout are integral to shopping at Target.
“Self-checkout was a game changer during the pandemic. To dial that back now feels like a loss of freedom.”
— Alicia Grant, Minneapolis Shopper
How this compares to industry trends
Target isn’t alone. Other national retailers have also expressed concerns about the abuse of self-checkout systems. With increasing inflation, tight labor markets, and widespread economic uncertainty, stores are doubling down on measures to secure their profits. Some chains have even gone as far as removing self-checkout entirely in certain locations.
Though Target stands by its tested approach and insists it is not a permanent nationwide mandate, it signals a broader shift. Retailers may be moving toward a more curated checkout experience, one that favors smaller transactions and higher security than convenience at all costs.
How Target could balance convenience and security
To soothe tensions, Target may explore hybrid solutions. Some experts suggest implementing express full-service lanes for customers with more than 10 items but fewer than 20—to catch the “in-between” shopper. Others have proposed deploying more attendants at self-checkout areas to guide and assist rather than limit access entirely.
Training existing staff to offer flexible checkout options during high-traffic hours or using app-based scanning software to scan as you shop are other options that have been proposed by analysts and shoppers alike. Ultimately, the key lies in options: giving the customer control while still securing store assets.
“Successful retail isn’t about technology alone—it’s about empowering the customer experience through smart policies.”
— Marcus Lin, Technology & Operations Analyst
Looking ahead to the holiday season
The timing of the policy rollout couldn’t be more critical. The months leading into the holiday season are a crucial window for big-box retailers, typically seeing a major spike in foot traffic. Experts are predicting that if Target does not implement further support measures to ease congestion, the ten-item rule may backfire, leading to even greater dissatisfaction.
Increased signage, mobile checkout expansions, or digital appointment systems might all play roles in helping to mitigate annoyance. Still, much depends on how consistently the policy is enforced across store locations and how effectively Target communicates the reasons behind it to shoppers.
“Transparency, consistency, and genuine customer service are going to make or break this policy’s reception.”
— Danielle Ford, Consumer Behavior Researcher
What shoppers can do now
Until there’s a broader rollout or reversal, customers should be prepared to adapt. If you’re heading to Target with a large list, expect to use cashier-staffed lines. For quick errands—snacks, office supplies, home basics—the self-checkout option may still serve as the fastest alternative. Some locations may vary in enforcement, so be observant of store signage and staff instructions.
Customers concerned about accessibility or needing expedited service may consider speaking with store management about their needs. Alternatively, using the Target app for curbside or same-day delivery can streamline the experience and bypass the hassle of checkout entirely.
FAQs about Target’s new checkout policy
What is the new self-checkout policy at Target?
Target is restricting self-checkout use to customers with 10 items or fewer at select store locations to improve flow and reduce theft.
Which Target stores are affected by this change?
The policy is being tested in specific regions, particularly high-traffic urban areas. Expansion may depend on pilot results.
Why did Target make this change now?
Increased shrink and customer service concerns prompted the shift. Target aims to balance convenience with operational efficiency.
Can I still use self-checkout for orders over 10 items?
As of now, if your order exceeds 10 items, you’ll need to use traditional cashier-attended checkout lanes in the affected stores.
Are there exceptions for shoppers with disabilities?
Target states inclusivity remains a priority. Shoppers with accessibility concerns should speak to store staff for accommodations.
Will this policy roll out nationwide?
Currently, it’s a test initiative. Depending on success and shopper feedback, Target may consider broader implementation.
How does this affect curbside pickup or online orders?
The new policy only affects in-store self-checkout. Online orders and curbside pickup through the app remain unchanged.
What do I do if I’m unsure what applies at my local store?
Check for in-store signs or ask a team member. Each location may have different temporary implementations as part of the pilot.
About the Author
