When I was twelve, my older brother made me watch the original X-Men movie for the first time. I remember being mesmerized by Jean Grey’s psychic powers – the way she could move objects with her mind and hear other people’s thoughts. That scene where she loses control and her abilities spiral into something terrifying stuck with me for weeks.
Now, decades later, I’m getting those same chills watching Star Trek: Starfleet Academy. The latest episode has taken the show into unmistakably X-Men territory, and fans are absolutely loving it.
The parallels between Marvel’s gifted mutants and the cadets at Starfleet Academy aren’t accidental. Show creators Alex Kurtzman and Noga Landau have openly acknowledged drawing inspiration from both X-Men and Harry Potter, creating what feels like Professor Xavier’s school meets Hogwarts in the 32nd century.
When Psychic Powers Meet Starfleet Training
Episode 6, “Come, Let’s Away,” showcases Tarima Sadal’s Betazoid telepathic abilities in a way that would make Jean Grey proud. Zoë Steiner’s performance captures that delicate balance between incredible power and the fear of losing control – something X-Men fans know all too well.
“What we’re seeing with Tarima is the classic struggle of someone discovering they’re more powerful than they ever imagined,” explains one long-time Star Trek analyst. “It’s the Jean Grey arc, but within the structured environment of Starfleet Academy.”
The episode escalates tension and violence as Tarima unleashes her psychic powers, creating moments that feel ripped straight from an X-Men comic. The visual effects team deserves credit for making her telepathic abilities feel both beautiful and terrifying.
Unlike previous Star Trek series where telepathic characters like Deanna Troi used their abilities more passively, Starfleet Academy pushes these powers to their limits. We’re seeing what happens when young people with extraordinary abilities are still learning to control them.
The Academy’s Extraordinary Student Body
The diversity of abilities among the cadets reads like a superhero team roster. Here’s what makes each character special:
- Tarima Sadal (Zoë Steiner) – Betazoid with powerful telepathic abilities, serving as the show’s Jean Grey equivalent
- Jay-Den Kraag (Karim Diané) – Klingon cadet with enhanced physical strength and combat instincts
- SAM (Kerrice Brooks) – Photonic being capable of manipulating light and energy
- Darem Reymi (George Hawkins) – Shapeshifting Khionan who can alter his physical form
- Genesis Lythe (Bella Shepard) – Dar-Sha with superhuman visual perception
- Caleb Mir (Sandro Rosta) – Human tech genius serving as the “ordinary” member of an extraordinary team
“The casting choices were brilliant,” notes a science fiction television critic. “Each actor brings something unique to their character’s abilities while maintaining that core Starfleet ideal of cooperation and growth.”
| Character | Species | Special Ability | X-Men Parallel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tarima Sadal | Betazoid | Telepathy | Jean Grey/Professor X |
| Darem Reymi | Khionan | Shapeshifting | Mystique |
| Genesis Lythe | Dar-Sha | Enhanced Vision | Cyclops |
| SAM | Photonic | Energy Manipulation | Storm |
What’s particularly clever is how the show uses Caleb as the audience surrogate. Like many viewers, he’s the “normal” human surrounded by beings with incredible abilities, making his journey of finding his place among them deeply relatable.
Why This Approach Works for Modern Star Trek
The X-Men influence brings something fresh to the Star Trek universe while staying true to its core values. Gene Roddenberry’s original vision always celebrated diversity and the idea that different beings could work together for a better future.
“We’re seeing Star Trek evolve to speak to a generation that grew up with superhero stories,” explains a entertainment industry insider. “The academy setting allows for that coming-of-age element that made both Harry Potter and X-Men so compelling.”
The show doesn’t shy away from the darker implications of having such powerful abilities. Episode 6’s violence and tension reflect the real struggles young people face when dealing with abilities they don’t fully understand or control.
This approach also allows Starfleet Academy to explore themes of acceptance, identity, and belonging in ways that feel both timeless and contemporary. The cadets aren’t just learning starship operations – they’re learning to be heroes.
The production values support this vision beautifully. The special effects make each character’s abilities feel distinct and meaningful rather than just flashy spectacle. Every power serves the story and character development.
What sets Starfleet Academy apart from other superhero properties is its optimistic foundation. Even when characters struggle with their abilities, the underlying message remains hopeful – these young people will grow into the heroes the galaxy needs.
“The beauty of combining X-Men elements with Star Trek is that you get the excitement of extraordinary powers within a framework that believes in the best of sentient beings,” observes a longtime franchise fan.
As the season progresses, viewers can expect to see more exploration of how these unique abilities shape both individual characters and team dynamics. The academy setting provides endless opportunities for growth, conflict, and resolution.
The show’s willingness to embrace its influences while carving out its own identity suggests a bright future for this corner of the Star Trek universe. Sometimes the best way to honor a legacy is to fearlessly evolve it.
FAQs
How is Starfleet Academy similar to X-Men?
The show features young people with extraordinary abilities learning to control their powers in a school-like setting, with clear parallels to Professor Xavier’s School for the Gifted.
Who is the most powerful cadet at Starfleet Academy?
Tarima Sadal appears to have the most potentially dangerous abilities as a Betazoid telepath, especially as shown in episode 6 when her powers escalate dramatically.
Why doesn’t Caleb have special abilities like the other cadets?
Caleb represents the “normal” human perspective, serving as an audience surrogate who proves that extraordinary abilities aren’t required to make a difference in the Star Trek universe.
Are the X-Men influences intentional in Starfleet Academy?
Yes, executive producers Alex Kurtzman and Noga Landau have confirmed they drew inspiration from both X-Men and Harry Potter when creating the show.
How does SAM’s photonic nature work as a cadet?
As a being of pure light and energy, SAM brings unique abilities to the team while exploring themes about artificial life and consciousness that are central to Star Trek.
Will we see more exploration of the cadets’ abilities in future episodes?
Given the show’s focus on character development and the academy setting, viewers can expect continued exploration of how each cadet’s unique abilities affect their training and relationships.
About the Author
