The physiotherapist looks almost apologetic as she speaks. “We’ve tried the pool, the bike, the classic stretches. Let’s test something more… controversial.” On the treatment table, Marc, 49, winces before even moving. Three years of knee pain, two MRIs, one pair of custom insoles, zero real relief. He’s been told to avoid deep bending “at all costs”. Now this specialist wants him to… squat.
Outside, the waiting room is full of the same story: people who can’t run after their kids, climb stairs without planning it, or stand through a concert. They’ve heard that swimming protects the joints, that Pilates “gently” strengthens everything. Yet the latest trend whispered between some sports doctors and rehab specialists is the exact opposite of what those cautious guidelines suggest.
The move everybody told you to quit might be the one thing that could help you get better.
The controversial comeback of squats for knee pain treatment
Across rehab clinics, a quiet revolution is taking place. Some practitioners are starting to say out loud what they’ve been thinking for years: avoiding squats forever might be keeping knees weak, not safe. They watch patients baby their legs, always stopping before the bend gets “too low”, living in a semi-squat limbo that never truly loads the joint.
For this new wave of experts, the real enemy isn’t bending—it’s fragility. The knee doesn’t just flex and extend in a lab. It twists when you get out of the car, absorbs shocks when you miss a step, locks and unlocks dozens of times a day. Training those movements, within reason, can be a form of protection instead of punishment.
“We’ve been so afraid of hurting people that we’ve forgotten how to help them get strong,” explains Dr. Jennifer Martinez, a sports medicine physician who now incorporates controlled squats into her knee rehabilitation programs. “The research is showing us that gradual loading can actually reduce pain and improve function in many patients.”
But here’s where it gets tricky. The medical community is far from united on this approach. Traditional orthopedic wisdom still leans heavily toward joint protection, especially for people with arthritis, previous injuries, or structural damage. The debate isn’t just academic—it’s affecting real treatment decisions for millions of people living with knee pain.
What the research actually shows about squats and knee health
The evidence supporting squats for knee pain isn’t just anecdotal. Recent studies have begun challenging long-held assumptions about what’s safe and what’s harmful for problem knees. Here’s what researchers are finding:
- Controlled loading reduces pain: Studies show that gradual, progressive squatting can decrease knee pain in people with patellofemoral pain syndrome
- Muscle strength improves function: Stronger quadriceps and glutes from squatting can better support the knee joint during daily activities
- Range of motion increases: Carefully performed deep squats can actually improve knee flexibility over time
- Real-world preparation: Squats train the exact movement pattern needed for chairs, toilets, and getting up from the floor
However, the devil is in the details. Not all squats are created equal, and the technique, depth, and progression matter enormously.
| Traditional Approach | New Squat-Based Approach |
|---|---|
| Avoid deep knee bending | Gradually work toward full range of motion |
| Focus on “safe” exercises like swimming | Include functional movements like squats |
| Protect the joint at all costs | Strengthen through controlled loading |
| Fear-based movement restrictions | Confidence-building progression |
Physical therapist Michael Chen, who has been using squats for knee pain treatment for over five years, puts it simply: “We’re not telling people to go from couch to deep squats overnight. We’re talking about a very careful, monitored progression that respects the individual’s current capacity.”
The real-world impact and who benefits most
The shift toward incorporating squats for knee pain isn’t happening in a vacuum. It’s driven by the limitations of traditional approaches and the growing understanding that movement, not rest, often holds the key to recovery.
Take Sarah, 38, an office worker who couldn’t pick up her toddler without knee pain. After months of avoiding anything that involved bending, she felt weaker than ever. Under careful supervision, she began with wall sits, progressed to partial squats, and eventually worked up to full-depth movements. Six months later, she’s playing at the park with her daughter again.
But this approach isn’t universally applicable. Certain conditions still warrant extreme caution or complete avoidance of squatting movements:
- Acute knee injuries or recent surgery
- Severe osteoarthritis with significant joint damage
- Unstable knee joints or ligament tears
- Active inflammation or swelling
The controversy stems partly from this complexity. “There’s no one-size-fits-all answer,” admits Dr. Robert Kim, an orthopedic surgeon who remains skeptical of the squat trend. “For every success story, I see patients who’ve been pushed too hard, too fast. The conservative approach exists for good reasons.”
This tension between innovation and caution is playing out in physical therapy clinics, doctors’ offices, and fitness centers across the country. Some practitioners are embracing the research and carefully implementing squat-based protocols. Others remain firmly in the “better safe than sorry” camp.
What’s clear is that the conversation around knee pain treatment is evolving. The days of blanket exercise restrictions may be numbered, replaced by more nuanced, individualized approaches that consider not just what might cause harm, but what might promote healing and long-term function.
For patients caught in the middle of this medical debate, the message is both hopeful and complex. Squats for knee pain might be the breakthrough some have been waiting for—but only under the right circumstances, with proper guidance, and with realistic expectations about the journey ahead.
FAQs
Are squats safe for everyone with knee pain?
No, squats aren’t appropriate for all types of knee pain. People with acute injuries, severe arthritis, or unstable joints should avoid them.
How deep should I squat if I have knee problems?
Start shallow and progress gradually under professional guidance. The depth depends on your specific condition and current mobility.
Can squats replace swimming and Pilates for knee rehabilitation?
Squats can complement other treatments but shouldn’t necessarily replace them. The best approach often combines multiple exercise types.
How quickly should I expect results from squatting for knee pain?
Most people notice improvements in strength and function within 4-6 weeks, but pain reduction may take longer and varies by individual.
Should I try squats on my own or work with a professional?
Given the controversy and complexity, working with a qualified physical therapist or sports medicine professional is strongly recommended.
What makes squats different from other knee exercises?
Squats train the exact movement pattern needed for daily activities like sitting and standing, making them more functionally relevant than many traditional exercises.
About the Author
