Sarah Martinez remembers the day her daughter came home from Bradford Central School with tears in her eyes. The high school had just announced they were cutting the art program due to budget constraints. “Mom, they’re taking away the only class I actually love,” her daughter said, slumping onto their kitchen table where homework papers were scattered.
That conversation happened three years ago, but Sarah still feels that knot in her stomach when she thinks about it. Like many parents in rural Steuben County, she’s watched her local school district struggle with tough decisions year after year. Now, Bradford Central School District and Campbell-Savona Central School District are exploring something that seemed unthinkable just a decade ago: combining into one unified system.
The school district merger discussions represent more than just administrative restructuring. They reflect the harsh reality facing small rural communities across New York State, where declining enrollment and shrinking budgets are forcing districts to make choices no parent wants to see.
Why These Districts Are Looking at Joining Forces
Both Bradford and Campbell-Savona have been walking a financial tightrope for years. State aid, which these districts depend on heavily, has grown slower than their actual costs. Meanwhile, they’re dealing with aging buildings, transportation challenges across vast rural areas, and the constant pressure to maintain quality education programs with fewer resources.
“We’re not talking about this merger because we want to,” explains a district official familiar with the discussions. “We’re talking about it because we need to explore every option to keep serving our students well.”
The numbers tell a sobering story. Both districts have seen their tax levies rise as they try to bridge the gap between what they receive and what they need. Parents have watched programs disappear, class sizes grow, and maintenance projects get postponed.
The joint feasibility study approved by both school boards will dive deep into every aspect of how a merger might work. They’re not just looking at the obvious stuff like combining administrative offices. They’re examining how to merge different academic programs, whether transportation routes make sense, and most importantly, what it would mean for taxpayers.
What the Merger Study Will Actually Examine
The feasibility study isn’t just a quick look at spreadsheets. It’s a comprehensive analysis that will take months to complete and cover these key areas:
- Academic Programs: How to combine curricula, maintain course offerings, and potentially expand opportunities for students
- Staffing and Personnel: Which positions could be consolidated, how to handle different contract agreements, and ensuring job security where possible
- Transportation Systems: Redesigning bus routes across a larger geographic area while keeping ride times reasonable
- Facilities Management: Determining which buildings to keep, which might be repurposed, and where to invest in infrastructure
- Financial Projections: Calculating actual savings, implementation costs, and long-term budget impacts
- Tax Implications: Understanding how property taxes might change for residents in each district
The study will also look at less obvious factors, like how to blend two different school cultures and maintain the community connections that make small districts special.
| Current Challenge | Potential Merger Benefit | Implementation Complexity |
| Duplicate administrative costs | Shared superintendent, business office | Medium – requires contract negotiations |
| Limited course offerings | Expanded academic programs | High – requires facility and scheduling coordination |
| Rising transportation costs | Optimized routes and shared resources | High – geographic challenges across rural areas |
| Maintenance backlogs | Consolidated facilities management | Medium – depends on facility decisions |
“The study needs to be brutally honest about both the benefits and the challenges,” notes an education finance expert who has worked on similar merger studies. “Rural district mergers can work, but they’re not automatic cost-savers.”
How This Could Change Life for Students and Families
For families like the Martinez household, a school district merger could mean dramatically different daily routines. Students might face longer bus rides to reach consolidated schools. Some might gain access to programs their current district can’t afford, like advanced placement courses or specialized vocational training.
The social dynamics matter too. In small schools, every student has the chance to be involved in sports, drama, or student government. A merged district might offer more opportunities overall, but individual students could face more competition for spots on teams or in programs.
“My son is the starting quarterback at Campbell-Savona,” explains one parent. “In a bigger merged school, he might not even make the team. But he might also have access to engineering classes we can’t offer now.”
Teachers are watching these discussions closely as well. A merger typically means some administrative positions get eliminated, though classroom teachers often see more job security in larger districts. The challenge comes in blending different teaching approaches and school cultures.
Transportation represents one of the biggest daily changes families would face. Rural students already spend significant time on buses, and a merger could extend those rides even further. However, it might also provide more reliable service and better-maintained vehicles.
Property owners are particularly concerned about tax implications. While merger proponents often promise tax savings, the reality is more complicated. Initial merger costs can be substantial, and savings might take years to materialize.
The Road Ahead: Community Input and Democratic Process
District officials are being careful to emphasize that approving a feasibility study doesn’t commit either community to anything. The actual merger process, if it moves forward, involves multiple approval steps designed to give residents control over the decision.
First, both school boards would need to vote again after reviewing the completed study. Then, assuming they both approve moving forward, the proposal would go to voters in each district. Both communities would need to approve the merger for it to happen.
“This is going to be a long conversation with lots of opportunities for input,” promises a school board member. “We want everyone to understand exactly what we’re considering and why.”
Public forums and information sessions are being planned once the study timeline is finalized. District leaders know they need to address concerns about everything from school mascots and traditions to bus routes and property taxes.
The feasibility study is expected to take several months, with preliminary findings likely available before the end of the current school year. Community input sessions will help shape the final recommendations.
Similar school district merger discussions are happening across rural New York and other states facing demographic and economic pressures. Some have succeeded in creating stronger, more sustainable school systems. Others have failed due to community opposition or implementation challenges.
FAQs
How long will the merger feasibility study take?
The study is expected to take several months, with preliminary findings available before the end of the current school year.
Who gets to vote on whether the merger actually happens?
Voters in both the Bradford and Campbell-Savona districts would need to approve any merger proposal for it to move forward.
What happens to school traditions and mascots in a merger?
These details would be worked out during the planning process, often with significant community input on preserving important traditions.
Will students definitely have longer bus rides if districts merge?
Not necessarily. The transportation study will look at optimizing routes, though some students may face longer commutes depending on facility decisions.
Are teacher jobs at risk in a school district merger?
While some administrative positions typically get consolidated, classroom teachers often have more job security in larger, merged districts.
Will property taxes go up or down after a merger?
Tax impacts vary significantly based on current tax rates, property values, and merger implementation costs. The feasibility study will provide specific projections for each community.
About the Author
