Sarah walked into the kitchen after a brutal day at work, dropped her laptop bag on the counter, and immediately knew she’d made a mistake. Her husband turned from the sink, water dripping from his hands, and said quietly, “You know, it would be nice if you asked about my day once in a while.” The words hit her like a cold slap, and she felt her shoulders tense. Her first instinct was to fire back about how exhausted she was, how she’d been thinking about bills all day, how he could have texted if something was wrong.
Instead, she took a breath and said something that surprised them both: “You’re right. Tell me about it.”
What happened next changed how they talked to each other forever. The defensiveness that usually turned their kitchen into a battlefield simply evaporated. Her husband’s expression softened, his voice dropped, and instead of an argument, they had their first real conversation in weeks.
Why Our Brains Choose War Over Understanding
When someone points out something we’ve done wrong, missed, or failed at, our nervous system doesn’t pause to analyze whether they’re being fair. It detects threat and immediately starts building walls. This response happens faster than conscious thought.
“The moment we feel criticized, our amygdala fires up and we’re in fight-or-flight mode,” explains Dr. Jennifer Martinez, a relationship therapist who’s studied communication patterns for over a decade. “Most people think defensiveness protects them, but it actually makes everything worse.”
Defensiveness feels protective, but it sends a clear message to the other person: “Your feelings don’t matter, and I’m not going to listen.” This triggers their own defensive response, creating what psychologists call a “negative feedback loop.” Both people end up feeling more misunderstood than when they started.
The simple response that can reduce defensiveness isn’t what most people expect. It’s not an elaborate technique or a memorized script. It’s two words: “You’re right.”
Before you dismiss this as impossible or weak, understand what these words actually do. They don’t mean you’re accepting blame for everything or admitting you’re a terrible person. They mean you’re acknowledging that the other person’s experience is valid, even if it’s not the whole story.
The Science Behind Why This Works
Research from the Gottman Institute shows that successful couples have one thing in common: they validate each other’s perspectives before defending their own. When you say “You’re right” to someone who’s upset, you’re doing several powerful things simultaneously:
- Signaling that you’re listening instead of preparing your defense
- Acknowledging their emotional experience as real and important
- Creating space for them to explain without feeling attacked
- Showing that you’re willing to be vulnerable instead of combative
- Breaking the pattern that usually leads to escalation
“When someone feels truly heard, their need to keep pushing usually disappears,” notes Dr. Robert Chen, who specializes in conflict resolution. “Most arguments aren’t really about the surface issue. They’re about feeling dismissed or misunderstood.”
| Traditional Defensive Response | Result | Validating Response | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| “That’s not true” | Escalation | “You’re right, tell me more” | De-escalation |
| “You’re overreacting” | Increased anger | “You’re right, I can see you’re upset” | Feeling heard |
| “But I always…” | Invalidation | “You’re right, I should have…” | Validation |
| “You do the same thing” | Blame shifting | “You’re right, let’s figure this out” | Problem solving |
The key is specificity. Instead of a generic “You’re right,” try “You’re right, I have been checking my phone a lot during dinner” or “You’re right, I should have asked before inviting people over.” This shows you’re actually listening to their specific concern.
What Changes When You Stop Fighting and Start Listening
This approach doesn’t mean becoming a doormat or accepting unfair treatment. After you acknowledge their perspective, you can still share your own. The difference is that by then, the other person usually feels heard enough to actually listen to your side.
Mark Thompson, a marriage counselor who’s worked with over 2,000 couples, puts it simply: “The person who stops defending first wins. Not because they’re giving up, but because they’re changing the entire dynamic of the conversation.”
When defensiveness drops, several things happen naturally:
- The other person’s voice usually gets softer
- They start explaining instead of accusing
- You both move from positions to interests
- Solutions become possible instead of just blame
- The relationship gets stronger instead of damaged
This doesn’t work in every situation. If someone is being abusive, manipulative, or consistently unfair, validation isn’t the answer—boundaries are. But in normal conflicts between people who care about each other, this simple shift can transform everything.
The hardest part isn’t learning to say “You’re right.” It’s catching yourself in that split second when your brain is loading up its defensive weapons. That moment when you feel your jaw clench and your mental lawyer starts preparing your case.
“Most of us have been trained to think that admitting we’re wrong is dangerous,” explains Dr. Lisa Park, who studies communication patterns. “But the real danger is in being so focused on being right that we forget to be kind.”
The next time you feel that familiar tightness in your chest during a conversation, try pausing for just two seconds. Ask yourself: do I want to be right, or do I want to be close? Sometimes, choosing closeness over correctness opens up possibilities that being defensive never could.
It takes practice. Your first instinct will still be to defend, explain, or deflect. But each time you choose validation over defense, you’re rewiring both your brain and your relationships. You’re showing the people you care about that their feelings matter more than your ego.
And surprisingly often, when you stop fighting their perspective, they stop fighting yours too.
FAQs
What if I say “You’re right” but I genuinely believe they’re wrong?
You’re not agreeing with facts, you’re validating their emotional experience. You can acknowledge their feelings are real without accepting their entire interpretation.
Won’t people take advantage of me if I stop being defensive?
Healthy relationships improve when you validate others’ perspectives. If someone consistently takes advantage of your openness, that’s a separate relationship problem requiring boundaries.
How do I remember to do this when I’m already upset?
Start practicing during calm moments and small disagreements. The more you use this technique in low-stakes situations, the more automatic it becomes during bigger conflicts.
What if they keep attacking after I validate them?
Sometimes people need time to process that you’re actually listening. Give them space to express themselves fully before sharing your perspective.
Can this technique work in professional settings?
Absolutely. Saying “You’re right, let me understand your concern” can reduce defensiveness in workplace conflicts and improve professional relationships.
What’s the difference between validation and agreement?
Validation acknowledges someone’s experience as real and understandable. Agreement means you think they’re factually correct. You can validate without agreeing.
About the Author
