Sarah Martinez still remembers the night she discovered “The Passage” on her bookshelf. It was 2019, and she’d just finished binge-watching every zombie show she could find. When she picked up Justin Cronin’s novel, she had no idea she was about to dive into one of the most gripping postapocalyptic sci-fi stories ever written. Three days later, she emerged from her reading marathon completely transformed by the experience.
Then Fox announced they were adapting it for television. Sarah’s excitement was palpable – finally, someone would bring this incredible world to life on screen. But after just one season, the show was cancelled, leaving fans like Sarah devastated and wondering what went wrong with such promising source material.
This scenario played out for thousands of readers who had fallen in love with Cronin’s trilogy. The cancellation of “The Passage” after just ten episodes represents one of television’s most frustrating missed opportunities in recent memory.
Why “The Passage” Deserves Another Shot at Television Glory
Justin Cronin’s “The Passage” trilogy isn’t just another postapocalyptic sci-fi story. It’s a masterfully crafted narrative that spans over a century, following humanity’s struggle against vampire-like creatures called Virals. The story begins with a government experiment gone wrong and evolves into an epic tale of survival, hope, and redemption.
Fox’s 2019 adaptation had all the right ingredients: a compelling cast including Mark-Paul Gosselaar and Saniyya Sidney, impressive special effects, and source material that had already proven its worth with readers worldwide. Yet the show struggled to find its audience and was cancelled after just one season.
“The problem wasn’t the story itself,” says television industry analyst Michael Chen. “It was the execution and timing. Fox tried to compress too much of the first book into ten episodes, losing some of the character development that makes the novels so compelling.”
The original novels work on multiple levels. They’re simultaneously intimate character studies and sweeping postapocalyptic epics. Cronin creates a world where scientific hubris leads to humanity’s near-extinction, but also where love, sacrifice, and human connection ultimately triumph over darkness.
What Made Fox’s Adaptation Fall Short of Expectations
Several factors contributed to the show’s premature demise, despite its promising foundation:
- Rushed pacing that compressed complex character arcs into abbreviated storylines
- Budget constraints that limited the scope of the postapocalyptic world-building
- Competition from other supernatural shows in an already crowded television landscape
- Marketing that failed to distinguish it from generic zombie content
- Scheduling conflicts that placed it against established hit shows
The show’s production team made significant changes from the source material, some of which alienated existing fans while failing to attract new viewers. Key plot elements were altered, character relationships were simplified, and the unique mythology that sets “The Passage” apart from other postapocalyptic sci-fi was diluted.
| Original Novel Elements | Fox Adaptation Changes | Impact on Story |
|---|---|---|
| Complex time jumps spanning decades | Linear timeline focused on immediate events | Lost epic scope and generational themes |
| Extensive character backstories | Streamlined character development | Reduced emotional investment |
| Gradual reveal of world mythology | Faster exposition and explanations | Diminished mystery and suspense |
“Viewers today are smarter and more patient than networks give them credit for,” explains entertainment critic Lisa Rodriguez. “Shows like ‘Game of Thrones’ and ‘Westworld’ proved audiences will invest in complex narratives if the payoff is worth it.”
The Perfect Storm for a Successful Reboot
Today’s streaming landscape offers unprecedented opportunities for complex, long-form storytelling that weren’t available when Fox first attempted the adaptation. Platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime, and HBO Max have demonstrated their willingness to invest in ambitious postapocalyptic sci-fi projects with proper budgets and creative freedom.
The timing couldn’t be better for a fresh adaptation. Recent successes like “The Last of Us,” “Station Eleven,” and “Sweet Tooth” have proven that audiences hunger for thoughtful postapocalyptic content that focuses on human connections rather than just survival horror.
Modern streaming services offer several advantages over traditional network television:
- Longer episode orders that allow for proper character development
- Higher production budgets for world-building and special effects
- Creative freedom from network censorship and advertising constraints
- Global distribution that can build international fanbase
- Binge-watching formats that suit complex narratives
“The streaming era is perfect for ‘The Passage,'” notes industry veteran Tom Harrison. “It’s exactly the kind of story that benefits from prestige treatment and patient storytelling.”
The postapocalyptic sci-fi genre has evolved significantly since 2019. Audiences now expect deeper character development, more sophisticated themes, and higher production values. A new adaptation could capitalize on these elevated expectations while staying true to Cronin’s original vision.
Why Fans and Industry Experts Believe in a Second Chance
The devoted fanbase for “The Passage” trilogy hasn’t diminished since Fox’s cancellation. Online communities continue to discuss the books, create fan art, and petition for a new adaptation. This sustained interest demonstrates the story’s enduring appeal and commercial potential.
Publishing industry data shows that sales of “The Passage” trilogy have remained strong, with new readers discovering the books regularly. The story’s themes of scientific responsibility, government overreach, and human resilience feel particularly relevant in today’s world.
Several high-profile showrunners have expressed interest in tackling the material again. The combination of proven source material, dedicated fanbase, and improved production capabilities creates an attractive package for streaming services looking for their next prestige project.
“Second chances in television are becoming more common,” explains media researcher Dr. Patricia Wong. “Shows like ‘Lucifer’ and ‘The Expanse’ found new life on different platforms. ‘The Passage’ deserves the same opportunity.”
The postapocalyptic sci-fi landscape has room for a story as unique as “The Passage.” While the market includes numerous zombie shows and dystopian dramas, Cronin’s blend of horror, science fiction, and human drama offers something distinctly different.
A successful adaptation could potentially spawn multiple seasons, covering all three books in the trilogy and potentially expanding into related content. The rich mythology and extensive timeline provide ample material for long-term storytelling success.
FAQs
Why was Fox’s “The Passage” cancelled after one season?
The show suffered from low ratings, rushed pacing, and strong competition from other supernatural dramas during its time slot.
What makes “The Passage” different from other postapocalyptic stories?
Unlike typical zombie narratives, it focuses on vampire-like creatures called Virals and spans over a century, emphasizing human connection and redemption themes.
Could another network or streaming service pick up “The Passage”?
Yes, streaming platforms have successfully revived cancelled shows before, and “The Passage” has the fanbase and source material to support a reboot.
How many books are in “The Passage” series?
Justin Cronin wrote a trilogy consisting of “The Passage,” “The Twelve,” and “City of Mirrors.”
What would a successful adaptation need to include?
A proper adaptation would need adequate episode count, higher production budget, and creative freedom to explore the complex mythology and character development.
Are the original novels still popular with readers?
Yes, the trilogy maintains strong sales and continues attracting new readers, demonstrating the story’s enduring appeal and commercial viability.
About the Author
