When the temperatures drop in New York City, residents expect their homes to be warm and livable. Unfortunately, for many New Yorkers, that isn’t always the case. Every winter, thousands of tenants report a lack of heat or hot water in their apartments—issues that can lead to severe discomfort, illness, or even legal battles. The good news is that New York City housing law is on your side.
Landlords are legally required to provide heat and hot water to tenants, especially during the Heating Season, which spans from October 1 to May 31 each year. Tenants facing these violations can, and should, report the issue to city authorities. Understanding your rights, knowing how to report a non-compliant landlord, and taking legal action if needed can make all the difference between suffering in silence and getting the protection you deserve.
Quick overview of heat and hot water requirements
| Requirement | Details |
|---|---|
| Heating Season | October 1 – May 31 |
| Daytime Temperature Law | Between 6AM–10PM, when it’s below 55°F outside, indoor temp must be at least 68°F |
| Nighttime Temperature Law | Between 10PM–6AM, indoor temp must be at least 62°F regardless of outside temp |
| Hot Water Requirement | Must be available 24/7, year-round, at a constant minimum of 120°F |
| Agency Responsible | New York City Housing Preservation & Development (HPD) |
| Reporting Method | Call 311 or use the 311 Online Portal |
What tenants are entitled to under the law
During the official Heating Season, landlords are mandated to maintain specific indoor temperature thresholds depending on the time of day and outdoor temperatures. If the temperature outside falls below 55°F during the day, the inside of your apartment must be at least 68°F. Regardless of the outdoor temperature at night, the apartment’s indoor temperature must not drop below 62°F between 10 PM and 6 AM.
Hot water is equally essential and is required by law to be available to tenants 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. The minimum required hot water temperature is 120°F. The failure to provide this basic utility can subject landlords to hefty penalties and even court intervention.
Enforcement and penalties for landlords
When a tenant reports a lack of heat or hot water to 311, the complaint is forwarded to the NYC Department of Housing Preservation & Development (HPD). HPD inspectors can visit the unit to verify the complaint. If a violation is confirmed, landlords are given a set timeframe to correct the issue—typically within 24 hours for heat and hot water deficiencies.
Fines for non-compliance are significant. Landlords can face civil penalties of up to $500 per day for each violation. In some cases, chronic offenders may be subject to enhanced enforcement actions or legal proceedings, including being taken to housing court by the city.
Heat and hot water aren’t luxuries—they’re essential services. The law makes it clear: if a landlord fails to provide them, swift action must be taken.
— Elena Morales, Tenant AdvocateAlso Read
Winter Storm Pushes Up U.S. Gas and Diesel Prices: Which States Are Running Low on Fuel?
How to file a heat or hot water complaint
If you are without heat or hot water, the first step is to notify your landlord or building super in writing. Landlords should be given the opportunity to fix the problem promptly. If there is no resolution within a reasonable timeframe, you should report the issue by calling 311 or using NYC’s 311 online system. Be ready to provide your address and a description of the issue.
Once the report is made, HPD will investigate the situation, often by sending an inspector to the location. If the inspector finds the unit in violation of the minimum housing maintenance standards, the landlord will be issued an official violation notice and must make repairs immediately or face fines.
Options for escalating unresolved complaints
For tenants whose issues are not resolved quickly, or who face repeat violations, further legal action can be considered. Tenants may file a complaint directly in Housing Court through an action called an HP (Housing Part) proceeding. This allows a judge to compel the landlord to make necessary repairs and may impose additional penalties.
In extreme cases, the court can appoint a 7A administrator to take over management of a building if landlords repeatedly fail to provide basic services like heat and hot water. This level of escalation is rare but reflects the seriousness with which the city treats these violations.
Tenants should never feel intimidated or helpless. Housing Court exists to enforce your rights when all else fails.
— Joel Kim, NYC Housing Attorney
Additional support services for tenants
Besides enforcement mechanisms, tenants also have access to advocacy groups and non-profit organizations that specialize in housing justice. These groups can assist in filing complaints, provide legal representation, and help tenants understand their rights. Legal Aid and tenant unions across NYC provide critical support in cases of neglectful or abusive landlords.
In many cases, organized tenant efforts can increase accountability. When entire buildings experience systematic heating issues, coordinated complaints and community pressure can drive quicker results and better enforcement.
Who’s most impacted by these violations
Low-income tenants, elderly residents, and families with young children are often the most severely impacted by the lack of heat and hot water. These groups are particularly vulnerable to cold-related illnesses, including hypothermia and respiratory issues. COVID-19 conditions have also amplified the dangers as more people spend time indoors.
Boroughs like the Bronx and parts of Brooklyn report some of the highest volumes of heat-related complaints during winter months. Language barriers, fear of retaliation, or lack of awareness often keep affected tenants from reporting violations, compounding the problem.
Winners and losers under current enforcement
| Winners | Losers |
|---|---|
| Tenants who document and report violations | Negligent landlords with repeat offenses |
| Housing advocates and legal aid groups | Landlords in poorly maintained buildings |
| Communities with active tenant unions | Tenants unaware of their rights |
Steps landlords must take to comply
Property owners are responsible for maintaining heating and hot water systems in good working order. This includes routine maintenance, inspections before Heating Season, and contingency planning for system failures. Landlords must maintain temperature logs and respond to tenant complaints immediately. Using certified contractors and responding within statutory time limits helps avoid fines and legal issues.
If a building’s heating system is inadequate or outdated, landlords must invest in modern upgrades. NYC has programs and incentives for energy efficiency improvements which may assist in these costs.
Short FAQs on reporting heat or hot water issues in NYC
How quickly must a landlord fix a heat or hot water issue?
Typically within 24 hours of the violation report. HPD may extend or escalate enforcement if delays occur.
Can I withhold rent if my apartment doesn’t have heat?
Technically yes, but always consult with a housing attorney before doing so. This may lead to eviction proceedings if not handled properly.
Is there a fee to file a complaint with 311 or HPD?
No. Filing a complaint is free and can be done anonymously if preferred.
What should I do if the building owner retaliates after my complaint?
Retaliation is illegal. You should document everything and contact a tenant advocacy group or legal aid organization immediately.
How can I prove that my apartment is too cold?
Use a room thermometer and document the temperature throughout the day. Photos with timestamps are helpful as evidence.
Can HPD fine landlords automatically?
No. Fines are imposed after inspectors verify violations and issue an official notice. Continued non-compliance increases penalties.
What if my entire building lacks heat?
Coordinate with your neighbors to file multiple complaints. This increases the priority level for inspections and enforcement.
Do I need to hire a lawyer to file in Housing Court?
No, you can file an HP proceeding without a lawyer, although having legal assistance can improve your chances of success.
Remember, the right to a warm, safe, and habitable home is not just a comfort—it’s a legal guarantee. Knowing how to act on that right is the first step toward securing just housing for all New Yorkers.
About the Author
