Sarah had been scrolling through Apple TV for what felt like an eternity, searching for something to watch with her partner on Valentine’s night. Every romantic comedy felt predictable, every drama too heavy for their cozy evening plans. Then she stumbled upon a film starring Elizabeth Olsen that promised something different – a love story that spans beyond death itself.
What Sarah didn’t realize was that she was part of a massive wave of viewers making the same choice. Within days of its streaming debut, this Elizabeth Olsen movie would climb to the very top of Apple TV’s charts, dethroning one of the most anticipated films of the year.
That film is “Eternity,” and its meteoric rise on streaming platforms tells us something fascinating about what audiences really want right now.
How Elizabeth Olsen’s “Eternity” Conquered Streaming
The Elizabeth Olsen movie “Eternity” officially launched on Apple TV+ on February 13, 2025, strategically timed just before Valentine’s Day. Within four days, it had completely overtaken Brad Pitt’s highly anticipated sports drama “F1” to claim the number one spot on Apple TV’s movie charts.
This wasn’t just a small victory either. “F1” had dominated streaming conversations for weeks, backed by massive marketing budgets and A-list star power. Yet viewers chose something entirely different – a fantasy romantic comedy about love, death, and impossible choices.
“The timing couldn’t have been more perfect,” says streaming analyst Maria Rodriguez. “Valentine’s Day weekend gave ‘Eternity’ the perfect launch window, but the film’s unique premise kept viewers talking long after the holiday ended.”
The story follows Joan, played by Elizabeth Olsen, who faces an extraordinary dilemma in the afterlife. She must choose between her husband of 65 years, Larry (Miles Teller), and her first love, Luke (Callum Turner), as her eternal partner. It’s a concept that immediately grabs attention and refuses to let go.
Breaking Down the Streaming Success Numbers
According to FlixPatrol data, “Eternity” didn’t just edge out the competition – it completely dominated Apple TV’s top 10 movies list. Here’s how the current rankings stack up:
| Rank | Movie Title | Genre | Previous Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eternity | Fantasy Romance | New Entry |
| 2 | F1 | Sports Drama | 1 |
| 3 | Fountain of Youth | Adventure | 3 |
| 4 | Fly Me to the Moon | Romance | 4 |
| 5 | The Lost Bus | Drama | 5 |
The Elizabeth Olsen movie also boasts impressive critical reception, maintaining a 76% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes after 187 professional reviews. This combination of critical acclaim and audience appeal created the perfect storm for streaming success.
Several factors contributed to this remarkable performance:
- Strategic Valentine’s Day release timing
- Elizabeth Olsen’s growing fanbase following her Marvel success
- Unique premise that stands out in a crowded market
- Strong word-of-mouth recommendations on social media
- High-quality production values from A24
“What we’re seeing with ‘Eternity’ is proof that audiences crave original storytelling,” explains entertainment industry expert James Chen. “While big-budget spectacles like ‘F1’ certainly have their place, viewers are drawn to films that offer genuine emotional depth and unique concepts.”
What This Means for Streaming and Elizabeth Olsen’s Career
The success of this Elizabeth Olsen movie represents more than just impressive streaming numbers – it signals a shift in how audiences discover and consume content. Valentine’s Day releases have traditionally been theatrical events, but “Eternity” proves that streaming platforms can create their own cultural moments.
For Elizabeth Olsen, this victory solidifies her transition from Marvel superhero to versatile leading actress. After years of playing Wanda Maximoff, she’s now proven she can carry entirely different types of films to major commercial success.
“Elizabeth brings such authenticity to Joan’s impossible choice,” notes film critic Rebecca Thompson. “She makes you believe in a love story that transcends death itself, which isn’t easy to pull off.”
The film’s success also highlights the growing power of streaming-first releases. While “Eternity” did have a limited theatrical run starting November 26, 2025, its real cultural impact came through its streaming debut. This pattern is becoming increasingly common as studios recognize the reach and immediacy of digital platforms.
Apple TV+ particularly benefits from this success, as it continues building its reputation for quality original content. The platform has been steadily investing in unique films and series, and “Eternity” represents exactly the kind of breakout hit that justifies those investments.
The cast supporting Elizabeth Olsen also deserves recognition. Miles Teller and Callum Turner create compelling romantic rivals, while supporting performances from Da’Vine Joy Randolph, John Early, and Olga Merediz add depth to the afterlife world director David Freyne has created.
This streaming triumph also demonstrates how smaller, character-driven films can compete with massive blockbusters when they offer something genuinely different. “F1,” despite its star power and high-octane premise, couldn’t match the emotional resonance that “Eternity” provided to audiences seeking meaningful entertainment.
The film’s journey from Toronto International Film Festival premiere to streaming chart-topper shows how festivals continue serving as launching pads for eventual commercial success. Its September 2025 TIFF debut generated positive buzz that carried through to its theatrical and streaming releases months later.
FAQs
What is Elizabeth Olsen’s new movie “Eternity” about?
“Eternity” follows Joan, who must choose between her husband of 65 years and her first love as her eternal partner in the afterlife.
When did “Eternity” start streaming on Apple TV+?
The Elizabeth Olsen movie began streaming on Apple TV+ on February 13, 2025, just before Valentine’s Day.
Who else stars in “Eternity” alongside Elizabeth Olsen?
The film co-stars Miles Teller as Larry, Callum Turner as Luke, and features Da’Vine Joy Randolph, John Early, and Olga Merediz in supporting roles.
How well has “Eternity” been received by critics?
The film currently holds a 76% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 187 professional reviews.
Did “Eternity” have a theatrical release before streaming?
Yes, the movie had a limited theatrical release starting November 26, 2025, after premiering at the Toronto International Film Festival.
What movie did “Eternity” replace at the top of Apple TV charts?
Elizabeth Olsen’s “Eternity” overtook Brad Pitt’s sports drama “F1” to claim the number one position on Apple TV’s movie rankings.
About the Author
