When David cleaned out his media cabinet last spring, he felt good about himself. The stack of DVDs had been gathering dust for years—who watches physical media anymore? He drove to his local charity shop, handed over three boxes of movies, and walked away with that warm feeling you get from doing something decent.
Three months later, browsing online for a replacement copy of a film he’d given away, David stumbled across something that made his stomach drop. There was his exact DVD—same cover, same slight crack in the case he remembered—listed as a “rare collectible” for $85. The seller’s profile showed dozens of other titles he recognized from his donation.
That charity shop donation had become someone else’s side hustle.
The Hidden World of DVD Donation Reselling
David’s experience isn’t unique. Across the country, a quiet ecosystem has emerged where donated DVDs get cherry-picked and resold at massive markups. What donors imagine as simple charity has become a sophisticated operation for people who know which titles to grab.
“I see the same faces every week,” says Maria Santos, who volunteers at a Goodwill in Portland. “They come in with smartphones, scanning barcodes before the DVDs even hit the shelves. They know exactly what they’re looking for.”
The process works like this: Professional resellers, often called “pickers,” monitor donation centers and thrift stores. They’ve memorized which DVD releases are valuable—first editions, out-of-print titles, foreign imports, limited steelbook cases. While regular shoppers browse casually, these experts work methodically through every donation.
The profit margins can be staggering. A DVD donated for free and sold by the charity for $2 might end up listed online for $50 or more if it’s the right title. Horror movies from the early 2000s, anime series with original packaging, and criterion collection films are particular goldmines.
Which DVDs Are Getting Targeted
Not every DVD is worth a reseller’s time, but certain categories consistently get plucked from charity shelves before regular customers even see them. Understanding what these pickers look for reveals just how organized this operation has become.
| DVD Category | Donation Price | Resale Value | Why It’s Valuable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Out-of-print horror films | $1-3 | $30-150 | Cult following, limited releases |
| Anime series (complete) | $2-5 | $40-200 | Collector demand, expensive to replace |
| Criterion Collection | $3-5 | $25-80 | Prestige label, film student market |
| Disney vault titles | $2-4 | $20-100 | Limited availability periods |
| Foreign films with subtitles | $1-3 | $15-60 | Hard to find, niche audiences |
The most valuable finds are often DVDs that look ordinary to casual donors but represent specific moments in film history. A scratched-up copy of a B-horror movie from 2003 might seem worthless, but if it’s the only official US release, collectors will pay serious money.
Professional pickers also target box sets and special editions. That “Lord of the Rings” extended edition you donated? If it includes the original packaging and all the bonus discs, it could be worth $60-100 to the right buyer, even used.
- First-run horror and sci-fi titles from independent studios
- Complete TV series sets, especially cancelled shows
- Foreign language films with English subtitles
- Music concert DVDs from major artists
- Educational or documentary series
- Anime with original Japanese audio tracks
The Real Impact on Donors and Charities
The DVD donation resold phenomenon creates a complicated web of winners and losers that goes beyond individual feelings of betrayal. While it might seem like harmless capitalism, the practice affects multiple groups in ways that aren’t immediately obvious.
For donors like David, the emotional impact runs deeper than financial loss. “I felt stupid,” he admits. “Like I’d been played. I started second-guessing every donation after that.” Many people report similar feelings—a mix of embarrassment and violation that changes how they approach charitable giving.
Charities face their own challenges. While they still receive some benefit from DVD donations, they’re essentially subsidizing resellers’ inventory. “We price things to move quickly and serve our community,” explains Janet Rodriguez, manager of a Salvation Army store in Denver. “But when people buy our $3 DVDs and immediately list them for $50, it feels like we’re missing out on revenue that could help more people.”
The practice also affects regular thrift store customers—families looking for affordable entertainment options. When the best DVDs get picked over by resellers, what remains on the shelves tends to be the least desirable titles. Parents searching for Disney movies or classic films for their kids often find empty sections or picked-over selections.
Some charity organizations have started adapting. They’re training staff to spot valuable items and price them accordingly, or setting aside potential collectibles for online auctions. “We realized we needed to get smarter about this,” says Rodriguez. “If something’s worth $50, why sell it for $3?”
But the adaptation isn’t universal. Many smaller charities lack the expertise or resources to properly evaluate donated media. They remain easy targets for experienced pickers who can process dozens of DVDs in minutes, identifying the valuable ones instantly.
The psychological effect on donors extends beyond individual disappointment. When people discover their donations being resold at high markups, many report feeling less inclined to donate in the future. This could potentially impact the broader charitable ecosystem, though the long-term effects remain unclear.
“The trust factor is huge in charitable giving,” notes Dr. Sarah Chen, who studies philanthropic behavior at Georgetown University. “When donors feel like their generosity is being exploited, even indirectly, it can change their relationship with giving altogether.”
For the resellers themselves, it’s simply business. They argue they’re providing a service—connecting rare items with collectors who truly want them, and paying fair market prices to charities. From their perspective, they’re just more knowledgeable customers.
The debate raises interesting questions about the nature of donation and fair market value. Should charities price items at their true market worth? Is it ethical to profit from donations meant to help others? There’s no clear consensus, and different communities are handling the issue in different ways.
FAQs
Is it legal to buy donated DVDs and resell them for profit?
Yes, it’s completely legal. Once charities sell donated items, buyers can do whatever they want with them, including reselling at higher prices.
How can I tell if my donated DVDs are valuable before giving them away?
Check completed sales on eBay or Amazon for your specific titles and editions. Look for first printings, out-of-print releases, and special editions that might be worth more than you think.
Do charity shops know their DVDs are being resold?
Most are aware it happens, though the extent varies. Some have started training staff to identify valuable items, while others focus on quick turnover rather than maximizing individual item value.
What should I do if I find my donated items being resold online?
There’s no legal recourse since the transaction was completed legitimately. Some people use it as a learning experience for future donations, while others choose different charities or donation methods.
Are there ways to donate that avoid resellers?
Consider donating directly to libraries, schools, or community centers that keep items for their own use. You can also sell valuable items yourself and donate the cash instead.
Why are some old DVDs worth so much money?
Scarcity drives value. Many DVDs went out of print, streaming rights expired, or were never digitally released. Collectors pay premium prices for titles they can’t get anywhere else.
About the Author
