Last week, my eight-year-old nephew confidently declared that Swedish Fish taste like cherry while we were sharing a bag at the movies. His older sister rolled her eyes and insisted they were strawberry. Their mom chimed in with “I always thought they were just… red flavor?” This sparked a heated candy debate that lasted through the entire previews.
Turns out, we were all wrong. And if you’ve ever found yourself in a similar argument about these iconic red gummies, you’re about to have your mind blown.
The truth about Swedish fish flavor is more surprising than you might think. These beloved movie theater treats aren’t cherry, strawberry, or even that mysterious “red” flavor we’ve all come to accept. They’re something completely different.
The Real Swedish Fish Flavor Will Shock You
Swedish Fish are actually supposed to taste like lingonberry. Yes, you read that right – lingonberry, not cherry or strawberry. This small, tart red berry is incredibly popular in Scandinavian countries, particularly Sweden, where it’s used in everything from jams to meat dishes.
“Most Americans have never tasted a real lingonberry, so they naturally assume Swedish Fish taste like more familiar red fruits,” explains candy historian Rebecca Martinez. “But the original Malaco recipe was specifically designed to capture that distinctive lingonberry flavor that Swedish people know and love.”
The confusion makes perfect sense when you consider that lingonberries aren’t commonly found in American grocery stores. These small red berries have a unique taste profile – they’re tarter than cranberries but sweeter than currants, with a slightly pine-like undertone that’s distinctly Scandinavian.
Malaco, the Swedish candy company that created Swedish Fish in the 1950s, wanted to bring a taste of home to their gummy creations. The fish shape wasn’t random either – it represented Sweden’s strong fishing industry and maritime culture.
How Swedish Fish Conquered America
Swedish Fish made their way to American shores through a distribution partnership with Cadbury in the 1950s and 1960s. But something interesting happened during the transition – the lingonberry flavor became lost in translation.
American consumers, unfamiliar with lingonberries, began describing the flavor in terms they understood. Cherry became the most common guess, followed by strawberry and generic “red fruit.” The manufacturer didn’t correct these assumptions, and over time, the true flavor identity became candy folklore.
Here’s what makes Swedish Fish different from other American gummy candies:
- They don’t contain gelatin, giving them a chewier, stickier texture
- They’re made with potato starch instead of animal-derived gelatin
- The original recipe uses natural lingonberry flavoring
- They’re classified as “wine gums” in European candy terminology
- The fish shape specifically represents Swedish maritime culture
| Characteristic | Swedish Fish | Traditional American Gummies |
|---|---|---|
| Main Ingredient | Potato Starch | Gelatin |
| Texture | Chewy, Sticky | Bouncy, Elastic |
| Original Flavor | Lingonberry | Various Fruits |
| Shape Significance | Cultural (Swedish Fishing) | Decorative |
“The texture difference is actually a dead giveaway about their European origins,” notes food scientist Dr. James Patterson. “American candy makers typically use gelatin, but European manufacturers often prefer starch-based formulations that create that characteristic chewy texture.”
What This Means for Candy Lovers Today
Modern Swedish Fish sold in the United States are manufactured in Canada and Turkey, not Sweden. This means the flavor has likely evolved from the original lingonberry recipe to something more palatable to North American tastes.
Many candy enthusiasts who travel to Sweden report that authentic Swedish Fish taste noticeably different from the American versions. The European versions maintain more of that distinctive lingonberry tartness, while American versions have become sweeter and more generic over the decades.
This flavor evolution isn’t uncommon in the candy world. Many international treats undergo subtle recipe changes when they’re adapted for different markets. Kit Kats taste different in Japan than they do in America, and even Coca-Cola varies slightly between countries.
“Food manufacturers often modify flavors based on local preferences and ingredient availability,” explains marketing researcher Lisa Chen. “What started as authentic lingonberry flavor has gradually shifted toward what American consumers expect from red candy.”
For those curious about the original taste, lingonberry jam and preserves are becoming more available in specialty food stores and online. The flavor is complex – imagine if cranberries and raspberries had a slightly piney, Nordic cousin.
Swedish Fish remain the 10th most popular movie theater candy in America and consistently rank in the top 20 Halloween treats. Their success proves that sometimes the mystery is more appealing than the truth. After all, “lingonberry fish” doesn’t quite have the same ring as “Swedish Fish.”
The next time you bite into one of these red gummies, you’ll know you’re tasting a diluted version of a distinctly Scandinavian flavor that most Americans have never experienced in its pure form. It’s a sweet reminder of how global our candy aisles have become, even when we don’t realize it.
FAQs
Are Swedish Fish really from Sweden?
Yes, they were originally created by Malaco, a Swedish candy company, in the 1950s, though most sold in America today are manufactured in Canada or Turkey.
Do Swedish Fish contain gelatin?
No, Swedish Fish are made with potato starch instead of gelatin, making them accidentally vegan-friendly and giving them their distinctive chewy texture.
What does lingonberry actually taste like?
Lingonberries are tart and slightly sweet, similar to cranberries but with a more complex, slightly piney flavor that’s popular in Scandinavian cuisine.
Why are they called “wine gums” in Europe?
The term “wine gums” refers to small, chewy candies meant to be savored slowly, like wine. They don’t actually contain alcohol.
Can I buy authentic Swedish Fish with the original flavor?
You can find closer-to-original versions in Scandinavian specialty stores or online, though the flavor has evolved significantly in American markets.
Why don’t more people know about the lingonberry connection?
Since lingonberries aren’t common in America, consumers naturally assumed the red candy was cherry or strawberry flavored, and manufacturers never corrected this misconception.
About the Author
