Most drivers know about the penny test — the tried-and-true method of checking your tire tread depth with just a coin. But what many don’t realize is that failing this simple test can now result in **hundreds of dollars in fines and potential vehicle impoundment**, as police across the country are stepping up enforcement of tire-safety regulations. Whether you’re a daily commuter or a weekend driver, staying compliant is about more than just safety — it’s about protecting your wallet too.
Law enforcement officials are cracking down on unsafe tires more than ever, emphasizing that worn-out tread isn’t just dangerous — it’s illegal. The simplicity of the penny test is now leading to complex consequences for unsuspecting drivers who ignore or overlook its significance. If Abraham Lincoln’s head disappears when you place a penny upside down in your tire grooves, you’re already at legal risk — and police are keenly aware of it.
Quick overview: new focus on tire safety enforcement
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Enforcement Focus | Increased due to rising tire-related accidents and inspections |
| Legal Minimum Tread | 2/32 inch in most states, matching penny test threshold |
| Common Violation Fine | $100–$400 per bald tire, plus possible vehicle towing |
| What Police Check | Tread depth, tire wear patterns, dry rot, and sidewall damage |
| Avoidance Tips | Routinely use penny test, rotate tires, check inflation, replace early |
Why the penny test matters more than ever
The penny test has long been a DIY solution for drivers to spot dangerously low tread. By inserting a penny with Abraham Lincoln’s head facing down into the tire tread, if you can see the top of his head, it means there’s less than 2/32″ of tread — the legal minimum in most states. While many may have dismissed this as an old-school technique, **law enforcement officers are using the exact same test roadside**, backed by state safety codes.
With fatal road accidents linked to tire blowouts and hydroplaning on the rise, authorities are treating insufficient tread as a major contributor. From state troopers to city police departments, more officers are pulling over vehicles for tire violations, especially during heavy rains or winter weather periods when tread matters most.
“People overlook tires until it’s too late. Now it’s part of our vehicle safety checklist during every stop.”
— Officer James Mathers, Highway Patrol DivisionAlso Read
Australian Open 2026 Men’s Semifinals Live: Scores, Key Moments, and Who Reached the Final
What changed this year
Across multiple states, traffic enforcement divisions received new mandates in early 2024 to focus on underrun vehicle safety issues — and tire condition sits at the top of that list. With increasing insurance claims related to poor vehicle maintenance, officers are now routinely checking for tread compliance during traffic stops and accident responses.
While the law has not changed regarding the 2/32″ standard, the **frequency and severity of enforcement have shifted dramatically.** Previously, warnings were often issued, but now citations — each ranging from $100 to $400 per tire — are backed by rigorous documentation and even towing orders where necessary.
Drivers with commercial vehicles are especially affected, as multiple bald tires can amplify penalty costs and place a vehicle out of service immediately. Inspections now incorporate tire depth gauges and documentation photos, rather than officer discretion alone.
What police are looking for
During inspections, officers check for the following signs of non-compliance:
- Tread depth less than 2/32”
- Uneven wear patterns that may indicate suspension or alignment issues
- Exposed wire or cords which signifies severe tread loss
- Sidewall cracks or dry rot, especially in older tires
- Bulges or bubbles indicating potential blowout risk
Even if only one tire on the vehicle is below legal standards, citations can be issued. In some jurisdictions, multiple violations on one vehicle result in **stacked penalties** per tire, plus impoundment if the condition is deemed a public hazard.
“One low-tread tire can cause a crash — especially in rain. That’s why we no longer give verbal warnings.”
— Sgt. Michelle Laramie, City Traffic Enforcement Unit
Who’s most at risk for violations
Vehicle owners who drive high mileage annually without regular tire checks are commonly cited. Similarly, those driving in variable climates — including heavy rain-prone states or snowy regions — face **heightened scrutiny** from highway patrol units. Commercial fleets, delivery vans, rideshare vehicles, and even teenagers borrowing family cars are getting flagged during routine pullover checks.
Additionally, drivers with used or private-sale cars risk inheriting dangerously worn tires if the seller didn’t disclose their condition. Without performing personal inspections or using tools like the penny test themselves, buyers may unknowingly drive into legal and safety trouble.
How to avoid fines — step-by-step guide
Preventing a tire violation citation is simple with regular monitoring. Here’s how to stay within the law and ensure your tires are safe:
- **Perform the penny test every month** – Insert the coin in various tread areas on all four tires.
- **Keep tires inflated** – Check PSI monthly and before long drives.
- **Rotate tires every 5,000–6,000 miles** – Even wear prevents premature bald spots.
- **Replace before legal minimum** – Don’t wait till 2/32″; aim for replacement at 4/32” for best safety.
- **Buy quality tires** – Budget brands may wear faster; look for warranties and tread reviews.
Cost of non-compliance: More than just fines
Drivers caught with illegal tires often face much more than just immediate costs. Insurance carriers can **refuse claims** if it’s proven that tire condition contributed to an accident. If blowouts cause injury or property damage, courts may rule driver negligence, leading to legal liability.
Other hidden costs include mandatory towing fees (up to $250–$400), vehicle impound charges, court-ordered inspections, and potential loss of license points, particularly for repeat offenders or commercial drivers.
“People think tire problems are minor until it affects their insurance or lands them in small claims court.”
— Mark Reacher, Auto Insurance Claims Analyst
Who comes out ahead and who loses
| Winners | Losers |
|---|---|
| Drivers who check and rotate tires regularly | Those with bald or mismatched tires |
| Fleet managers with strong maintenance programs | Used vehicle buyers who don’t inspect tires |
| Drivers in compliance avoiding fines | Uninsured drivers fined for accidents caused by bad tires |
Short FAQs about tire fines and the penny test
How do I perform the penny test properly?
Insert a penny into your tire’s tread groove with Lincoln’s head facing down. If you can see all of his head, your tread is below 2/32”, and you need new tires immediately.
Is the penny test legally recognized?
Yes. While basic, the penny test aligns with the 2/32” legal tread minimum recognized in most U.S. states and is used by law enforcement as a quick roadside assessment.
What happens if an officer finds bald tires?
Officers can issue citations per tire, require immediate tire replacement, and even tow the vehicle if it’s deemed unsafe for road use.
Can I contest a tire violation ticket?
Yes, but you’ll need to present evidence your tires met legal standards at the time. This may include tire receipts, inspection records, or photographic proof.
How often should tires be replaced?
Most tires last between 25,000 and 50,000 miles depending on usage, brand, rotation habits, and climate exposure. Check tread monthly and aim to replace them before reaching the legal limit.
Do different states have different tread minimums?
Most U.S. states follow the federal 2/32” requirement, but some regional variations may exist, especially for winter tires. Always check local DMV guidelines.
Can insurance deny a claim due to bald tires?
Yes. If an accident investigation finds tire condition contributed, your insurer can deny or reduce the payout due to driver negligence.
Are tire tread checks included in annual inspections?
Usually yes. Most state vehicle inspections include tread depth evaluations. However, monthly personal checks are still critical in between official inspections.
About the Author
