Sarah Martinez was looking forward to watching her nephew’s hockey game Monday afternoon. She’d driven twenty minutes from Providence, bought snacks from the concession stand, and found a good spot in the stands at Dennis M. Lynch Arena. The atmosphere was electric – families cheering, kids pressed against the glass, the satisfying sound of skates cutting across fresh ice.
Then everything changed in an instant. What started as a celebration of youth athletics became a nightmare that no parent, grandparent, or community member should ever witness.
The Pawtucket shooting has left an entire community searching for answers, and now court records are revealing the complex web of family conflicts that may have led to this tragic day.
When Family Tensions Turn Deadly
The gunman who opened fire during Monday’s hockey game wasn’t a random stranger. Robert Dorgan, 56, of North Providence, had been battling his own demons and family disputes for years before the Pawtucket shooting claimed two lives and injured three others.
Court documents paint a picture of escalating tensions that began around 2020, when Dorgan’s personal journey and family relationships reached a breaking point. After undergoing gender-reassignment surgery, Dorgan – who also went by “Roberta” – faced rejection from those closest to him.
“Family conflicts don’t happen overnight,” explains Dr. Jennifer Walsh, a crisis intervention specialist. “They build up over months or years, and when someone feels isolated or rejected by their support system, the emotional pressure can become overwhelming.”
The shooting occurred just after 2:30 p.m. during what should have been an ordinary boys’ ice hockey matchup. Families had gathered to cheer on their kids, but instead found themselves diving for cover as multiple shots rang out across the arena.
A Paper Trail of Escalating Disputes
The court records surrounding the Pawtucket shooting suspect reveal a troubling pattern of family conflicts that stretched over several years. These documents show how personal struggles can spiral into dangerous territory when left unaddressed.
| Year | Incident | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | Dorgan reported threats from father-in-law after gender transition | Intimidation charges filed, later dropped |
| 2020 | Wife Rhonda filed for divorce citing “gender reassignment surgery, narcissistic traits” | Amended to “irreconcilable differences” |
| 2020 | Dorgan accused mother of assault | Case dismissed |
| 2021 | Divorce finalized | Dorgan moved to Jacksonville, Florida |
The most significant conflicts centered around Dorgan’s gender identity and the family’s response to his transition. According to police reports, Dorgan’s father-in-law allegedly pressured him to leave the family home and used derogatory language about transgender individuals.
Key elements from the court records include:
- Threats of violence from family members over housing arrangements
- Divorce proceedings that initially cited gender transition as a factor
- Allegations of assault involving Dorgan’s mother
- Claims of retaliation threats if legal charges weren’t dropped
- Geographic relocation suggesting family estrangement
“When someone feels rejected by their entire family system, it creates a perfect storm of isolation and anger,” notes family therapist Dr. Michael Chen. “The court records in this case show a pattern of escalating conflicts with no apparent resolution or healing.”
The Ripple Effects of Monday’s Violence
The Pawtucket shooting has sent shockwaves far beyond the arena walls. Local schools implemented additional security measures, parents are questioning the safety of youth sporting events, and mental health professionals are working overtime to help traumatized witnesses.
Students who were at the game are struggling to process what they saw. Many witnessed their first act of real violence, watching fellow community members fall victim to a dispute they couldn’t understand.
“These kids came to cheer for their team and ended up running for their lives,” explains school counselor Lisa Rodriguez. “The psychological impact of something like this extends far beyond the immediate victims.”
The families of those killed and injured are now facing their own long road to recovery. Hospital officials report that the three surviving victims are in stable condition, but the emotional wounds will take much longer to heal.
Local law enforcement agencies are also examining their own procedures. While the specific relationship between the shooter and victims hasn’t been fully disclosed, authorities have confirmed this was a “targeted” attack connected to personal disputes rather than random violence.
Community leaders are calling for increased mental health resources and better intervention programs for families experiencing severe conflicts. The tragedy has highlighted how personal disputes can escalate to devastating levels when warning signs go unaddressed.
Youth hockey programs across Rhode Island are now reviewing their security protocols. Many are questioning whether additional screening or security measures should be implemented at what were previously considered safe, family-friendly events.
“No parent should have to worry about their child’s safety at a school hockey game,” says parent advocate Maria Santos. “This shooting has changed how we think about community gatherings.”
The investigation continues as authorities piece together the exact sequence of events and explore whether any warning signs were missed. Mental health experts emphasize that while family conflicts are common, the escalation to violence represents a breakdown of multiple support systems.
FAQs
What happened during the Pawtucket shooting?
A gunman opened fire during a high school hockey game at Dennis M. Lynch Arena, killing two people and injuring three others before taking his own life.
Who was the shooter in the Pawtucket incident?
The shooter was identified as 56-year-old Robert Dorgan of North Providence, who also went by the name “Roberta.”
What do court records show about the suspect’s family conflicts?
Records reveal years of disputes involving Dorgan’s gender transition, divorce proceedings, allegations of threats from family members, and accusations of assault.
Were there warning signs before the Pawtucket shooting?
Court documents show a pattern of escalating family conflicts dating back to 2020, including police reports and legal proceedings involving threats and intimidation.
How is the Pawtucket community responding to the shooting?
The community is implementing additional security measures at youth events, providing mental health support for witnesses, and calling for better intervention programs for family conflicts.
What charges were previously filed against the shooter’s family members?
Intimidation and obstruction charges were briefly filed against Dorgan’s father-in-law in 2020 but were later dropped.
About the Author
