Sarah Martinez had just settled in for her Friday night movie marathon when she noticed something unexpected on her Apple TV+ screen. The usual suspects—action blockbusters and high-budget thrillers—weren’t topping the charts anymore. Instead, a romantic fantasy called “Eternity” had quietly climbed to the #1 spot, starring none other than Elizabeth Olsen.
“I wasn’t even looking for a love story,” Sarah laughs, “but something about seeing Wanda Maximoff in a completely different role just drew me in.” Like millions of other viewers, she clicked play and found herself swept into an afterlife romance that would soon dominate streaming conversations nationwide.
What happened next surprised everyone, including Hollywood insiders. This Elizabeth Olsen movie didn’t just perform well—it completely dethroned Brad Pitt’s highly anticipated Formula 1 drama from the top streaming spot.
When Romance Beats Racing: The Streaming Upset Nobody Saw Coming
Elizabeth Olsen’s latest venture, “Eternity,” has achieved something remarkable in the streaming world. The fantasy romantic comedy officially knocked Brad Pitt’s “F1” off Apple TV+’s #1 position just four days after its February 13th Valentine’s Day release.
The timing couldn’t have been more perfect. While F1 brought high-octane racing action and A-list star power, Eternity offered something different—an intimate story about love transcending death itself. The film follows Joan, played by Olsen, who faces an impossible choice in the afterlife between her husband of 65 years and her first love.
“It’s not often you see a mid-budget romantic film outperform a massive sports drama,” notes streaming analyst Rebecca Chen. “But Eternity tapped into something viewers were craving—genuine emotional connection.”
The film’s success represents a significant shift in streaming preferences. While action-packed blockbusters typically dominate charts, Eternity’s rise suggests audiences are hungry for character-driven stories that explore deeper themes.
The Numbers Behind Eternity’s Streaming Success
According to FlixPatrol data, Eternity’s performance has been nothing short of impressive. The film’s journey from theatrical release to streaming dominance tells a compelling story about modern viewing habits.
| Platform Ranking | Movie Title | Genre | Lead Actor |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Eternity | Fantasy Romance | Elizabeth Olsen |
| #2 | F1 | Sports Drama | Brad Pitt |
| #3 | Fountain of Youth | Adventure | Various |
| #4 | Fly Me to the Moon | Comedy Drama | Scarlett Johansson |
| #5 | The Lost Bus | Thriller | Various |
The Elizabeth Olsen movie’s stellar performance becomes even more impressive when you consider its competition. The current Apple TV+ top 10 includes several high-profile titles:
- F1 – Brad Pitt’s racing drama with massive marketing budget
- The Instigators – Action comedy featuring Matt Damon
- Ghosted – Ana de Armas and Chris Evans romantic action film
- The Family Plan 2 – Mark Wahlberg’s action sequel
- The Gorge – Supernatural thriller with significant promotion
“Eternity proves that star power and emotional storytelling still trump massive budgets,” explains entertainment journalist Mark Rodriguez. “Elizabeth Olsen has built incredible goodwill with audiences, and this film showcases her range beyond the Marvel universe.”
The film’s 76% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 187 reviews, demonstrates strong critical support alongside audience enthusiasm. This combination of critical acclaim and popular appeal has created the perfect storm for streaming success.
What This Means for Streaming and Elizabeth Olsen’s Career
The success of this Elizabeth Olsen movie signals several important trends in the entertainment industry. First, it demonstrates that audiences are actively seeking out character-driven narratives that explore complex emotional themes.
Streaming platforms are taking notice. Apple TV+ has already greenlit two additional romantic dramas for 2026, clearly influenced by Eternity’s performance. Other platforms are reportedly fast-tracking similar projects that blend fantasy elements with intimate relationship stories.
For Elizabeth Olsen personally, Eternity represents a crucial career milestone. After years of being primarily known for her role as Scarlet Witch in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, this film establishes her as a leading lady capable of carrying non-superhero projects.
“Elizabeth has always been a phenomenal actress, but Eternity lets her show vulnerability and depth that superhero films rarely allow,” says casting director Jennifer Walsh. “This performance will definitely open doors to more leading roles in prestige dramas.”
The film’s success also impacts her co-stars Callum Turner and Miles Teller, both of whom are seeing increased interest from major studios following Eternity’s streaming triumph.
Industry observers are particularly interested in how this success might influence future project development. The film’s modest budget compared to its massive streaming impact suggests that studios might prioritize story and character development over expensive action sequences.
Furthermore, Eternity’s Valentine’s Day release strategy has proven incredibly effective. The romantic timing, combined with the afterlife premise, created a unique viewing experience that audiences shared widely on social media.
“We’re seeing a 300% increase in social media mentions for romantic fantasy films since Eternity’s release,” reports digital marketing specialist Anna Thompson. “The film struck a chord that’s reverberating throughout the genre.”
The streaming success has also sparked discussions about theatrical versus streaming releases. Eternity performed moderately well in theaters during its November 2025 run, but its streaming performance has been exponentially stronger, raising questions about optimal release strategies for similar films.
Looking ahead, industry experts predict that Eternity’s success will encourage more established actors to take risks on unconventional romantic projects. The film proves that audiences are hungry for original stories that challenge traditional genre boundaries.
FAQs
What is Elizabeth Olsen’s new movie Eternity about?
Eternity is a fantasy romantic comedy where Elizabeth Olsen plays Joan, a woman who must choose between her husband of 65 years and her first love as her eternal partner in the afterlife.
When did Eternity start streaming on Apple TV+?
The Elizabeth Olsen movie began streaming on Apple TV+ on February 13, 2026, perfectly timed for Valentine’s Day weekend.
Who else stars in Eternity besides Elizabeth Olsen?
The film also features Callum Turner, Miles Teller, John Early, Olga Merediz, and Da’Vine Joy Randolph in supporting roles.
How well did Eternity perform critically?
The movie currently holds a 76% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 187 professional reviews, indicating strong critical support.
Which movie did Eternity replace at #1 on Apple TV+?
Elizabeth Olsen’s Eternity knocked Brad Pitt’s Formula 1 racing drama “F1” from the top spot on Apple TV+’s movie charts.
When did Eternity first premiere?
The film had its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 7, 2025, before its theatrical release on November 26, 2025.
About the Author
