Sarah had been waiting three years for someone to properly adapt her favorite detective novels. She’d devoured every single Harry Hole book by Jo Nesbø, staying up until 2 AM to finish each twisted Norwegian crime thriller. When “The Snowman” movie came out in 2017, she rushed to the theater with sky-high expectations.
Two hours later, she walked out feeling like someone had taken her beloved detective and turned him into a cardboard cutout. The movie was such a mess that even Michael Fassbender couldn’t save it. Sarah wasn’t alone in her disappointment—millions of Nesbø fans felt the same crushing letdown.
Now, Netflix’s Detective Hole series promises to do what Amazon’s Reacher did: take a botched movie adaptation and transform it into the faithful, gripping television series that fans deserve.
Why The Snowman Movie Failed Where Netflix’s Detective Hole Could Succeed
The 2017 film “The Snowman” became one of cinema’s most notorious disasters, earning just 7% on Rotten Tomatoes and leaving both critics and fans bewildered. Based on Jo Nesbø’s seventh Harry Hole novel, the movie suffered from production nightmares that resulted in an incoherent plot and wasted talent.
“The biggest mistake was trying to cram a complex, layered detective story into two hours,” explains crime fiction analyst Dr. Rebecca Martinez. “Harry Hole’s character development spans multiple books—you can’t just drop audiences into book seven and expect them to understand who he is.”
Netflix’s Detective Hole series appears to be taking the opposite approach. Rather than jumping into the middle of Nesbø’s series, the streaming platform is reportedly starting from the beginning, allowing viewers to witness Harry Hole’s evolution as both a detective and a deeply flawed human being.
The series also benefits from the television format’s natural advantages. Where movies compress everything into a tight runtime, TV shows can breathe. They can explore the psychological complexity that makes Nesbø’s novels so compelling, diving deep into Norway’s dark winter atmosphere and the personal demons that drive Harry Hole.
What Netflix’s Detective Hole Gets Right That The Movie Missed
The upcoming Netflix adaptation addresses several critical areas where “The Snowman” fell short:
- Character Development: TV format allows for gradual character building across multiple episodes
- Atmospheric Setting: More time to establish the haunting Norwegian landscape that’s crucial to the stories
- Complex Plotting: Room to properly develop the intricate mysteries that define Nesbø’s work
- Supporting Characters: Space to flesh out the ensemble cast that enriches the Harry Hole universe
- Cultural Authenticity: Opportunity to authentically portray Norwegian police procedures and society
The series reportedly features Norwegian actors and crew members, ensuring cultural authenticity that the Hollywood movie adaptation lacked. This attention to detail mirrors how Amazon’s Reacher succeeded by staying true to Lee Child’s vision of the character.
| Aspect | The Snowman (2017) | Netflix’s Detective Hole |
|---|---|---|
| Runtime | 119 minutes | Multiple seasons |
| Source Material | Single book (7th in series) | Starting from book 1 |
| Character Development | Limited | Long-term arc |
| Cultural Setting | Anglicized | Authentically Norwegian |
“Television gives us the luxury of time,” notes streaming content specialist James Chen. “We can watch Harry Hole make mistakes, learn from them, and gradually become the detective readers fell in love with.”
How This Could Change Crime Drama Adaptations Forever
The success of Netflix’s Detective Hole could reshape how streaming platforms approach literary adaptations. Rather than optioning individual books for movie treatments, studios are increasingly recognizing the value of long-form storytelling that honors the source material’s complexity.
This trend extends beyond just detective fiction. Viewers have shown they’re hungry for faithful adaptations that don’t rush through beloved characters’ development. The Reacher phenomenon proved that audiences will embrace slower-paced character building if it means getting the stories they love told properly.
For Jo Nesbø fans specifically, this represents a chance at redemption. The author’s Harry Hole series has sold over 55 million copies worldwide, creating a massive built-in audience that “The Snowman” movie squandered. Netflix’s approach suggests they understand what went wrong and are committed to doing better.
The ripple effects could be significant. Other Nordic noir authors like Henning Mankell, Stieg Larsson, and Camilla Läckberg might see renewed interest in television adaptations of their work. Publishers and literary agents are already taking notice of how streaming platforms can breathe new life into properties that failed on the big screen.
“We’re seeing a renaissance in book-to-screen adaptations,” explains entertainment industry insider Maria Rodriguez. “Shows like Reacher and potentially Detective Hole prove that respecting the source material pays off both critically and commercially.”
The timing couldn’t be better. Nordic noir has never been more popular globally, and Netflix’s international reach means Detective Hole could introduce Harry to audiences who’ve never heard of Jo Nesbø. If executed well, the series could become the definitive version of these characters, much like how Alan Ritchson’s Reacher has overshadowed Tom Cruise’s interpretation in many fans’ minds.
For Sarah and millions of other Harry Hole fans, Netflix’s Detective Hole represents hope. Hope that their favorite flawed detective will finally get the adaptation he deserves. Hope that complex, psychological crime fiction can find its proper home on television. And hope that sometimes, second chances really do work out better than first attempts.
FAQs
When will Netflix’s Detective Hole series be released?
Netflix hasn’t announced an official release date yet, but the series is currently in development and expected to debut sometime in 2024.
Will the Netflix series be better than The Snowman movie?
Early signs suggest it will be, as the series plans to start from the beginning of the book series and take a more faithful approach to the source material.
Who will play Harry Hole in the Netflix series?
The casting hasn’t been officially announced, but reports suggest Netflix is looking for a Norwegian actor to authentically portray the character.
How many Harry Hole books could the series adapt?
Jo Nesbø has written 12 Harry Hole novels, providing plenty of source material for multiple seasons if the series is successful.
Why did The Snowman movie fail so badly?
The movie suffered from production problems, tried to adapt the wrong book in the series, and failed to capture the atmospheric complexity of Nesbø’s writing.
Is Netflix’s Detective Hole connected to The Snowman movie?
No, the Netflix series appears to be a completely fresh start with no connection to the 2017 film adaptation.
About the Author
