The smell of bacon sizzling in the pan always takes me back to Sunday mornings at my childhood home. My mom would stand at the stove, her hair still in curlers, flipping strips of bacon while humming along to the radio. But this wasn’t just any breakfast preparation – she was making what our family called “my mom’s go-to” recipe that could save any mealtime disaster.
That recipe was Impossible Bacon Pie, a magical dish that came from the back of a Bisquick box and somehow managed to create its own crust while baking. My mom discovered it in the late 1970s, and it quickly became her secret weapon for busy weeknights, unexpected guests, and those moments when the dinner plan fell apart completely.
What made this recipe so special wasn’t just its convenience – it was how it brought our scattered family together around the dinner table, no matter what chaos the day had thrown at us.
The Magic Behind My Mom’s Go-To Recipe
Impossible Bacon Pie earned its name because it seemed impossible that such a simple mixture could transform into something so satisfying. The recipe belonged to Bisquick’s famous “Impossible” series, which included variations like Impossible Cheeseburger Pie and Impossible Cherry Pie.
The genius lay in the batter’s composition. When you combine Bisquick mix, eggs, and milk with your chosen fillings, something remarkable happens in the oven. The heavier ingredients sink to the bottom while the Bisquick mixture rises and forms a golden crust on top.
“These impossible pies were revolutionary for busy families in the 70s and 80s,” explains food historian Sarah Mitchell. “They gave home cooks a way to create what felt like a fancy quiche without the intimidation factor of making pastry from scratch.”
My mom’s go-to version combined crispy bacon, sautéed onions, and Swiss cheese – a combination that worked equally well for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The recipe called for ingredients most families already had on hand, making it perfect for those “what’s for dinner?” moments that every parent dreads.
Why This Recipe Became a Family Legend
Understanding why my mom’s go-to recipe achieved legendary status in our household requires looking at the practical realities of family life in the 1980s. Our schedules were chaotic – my father worked rotating shifts, my brother had evening jobs, and I stayed late for school activities.
The beauty of Impossible Bacon Pie was its flexibility and convenience:
- Could be prepared in advance and reheated in portions
- Required only basic cooking skills and common ingredients
- Satisfied both kids and adults with its comfort food appeal
- Cost-effective during tight budget periods
- Worked for any meal of the day
- Impressed guests despite its simple preparation
“The microwave oven was still relatively new technology then,” recalls cookbook author Janet Williams. “Recipes that reheated well were incredibly valuable to working families who needed flexibility in their meal timing.”
My mom would often make two pies at once – one for immediate consumption and another to cut into wedges and freeze for emergency meals. Those frozen portions became lifesavers during particularly hectic weeks.
| Basic Recipe Components | Quantity | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Bisquick mix | 1/2 cup | Forms the “impossible” crust |
| Eggs | 3 large | Provides structure and richness |
| Milk | 1 cup | Creates custard-like filling |
| Cooked bacon | 8 strips | Main protein and flavor |
| Swiss cheese | 1 cup shredded | Adds creaminess and depth |
| Onion | 1/4 cup chopped | Provides savory base note |
How This Simple Recipe Changed Family Dinners
The impact of my mom’s go-to recipe extended far beyond just solving the “what’s for dinner” problem. This simple pie became a symbol of reliability in our household – something we could count on when everything else felt unpredictable.
During my teenage years, when family schedules seemed impossible to coordinate, Impossible Bacon Pie became our common ground. No matter what time each family member arrived home, there was always a slice waiting in the refrigerator, ready to be reheated and enjoyed.
The recipe also marked my first real step into independent cooking. At age 14, I successfully made the pie entirely on my own, feeling incredibly accomplished when it emerged from the oven with its perfectly golden top and custardy interior.
“Learning to cook often starts with recipes that feel approachable and forgiving,” notes culinary educator Mark Rodriguez. “Box recipes like these gave novice cooks confidence to experiment in the kitchen.”
Years later, when I moved into my first apartment, my mom wrote out the recipe on a index card – one of only five recipes she insisted I needed to know. That card, now stained and worn, still lives in my recipe box today.
The recipe’s influence extends to the next generation as well. My own children have grown up enjoying their grandmother’s famous pie, and my daughter recently asked me to teach her how to make it. The cycle continues, proving that sometimes the simplest recipes create the most lasting memories.
What strikes me most about my mom’s go-to recipe is how it represented so much more than just a meal solution. It was about making the best of what you had, bringing family together despite busy schedules, and proving that love often comes in the form of a simple, reliable dish that never lets you down.
Food writer Lisa Chen puts it perfectly: “These family go-to recipes become part of our identity. They’re not just about feeding people – they’re about creating traditions and showing care through consistency.”
FAQs
What makes Impossible Bacon Pie “impossible”?
The batter magically forms its own crust during baking, with heavier ingredients sinking down while the Bisquick mixture rises to create a golden top crust.
Can you make this recipe ahead of time?
Yes, the pie can be prepared and baked in advance, then refrigerated for up to three days or frozen for up to three months in individual portions.
What other variations of impossible pies exist?
Bisquick created several versions including Impossible Cheeseburger Pie, Impossible Cherry Pie, Impossible Tuna-Dill Pie, and Impossible Pumpkin Pie.
Is this recipe suitable for beginner cooks?
Absolutely – it requires only basic mixing skills and common ingredients, making it perfect for novice cooks or busy families.
Can you substitute ingredients in the basic recipe?
Yes, the bacon can be replaced with ham, sausage, or vegetables, and different cheeses work well too, making it very adaptable to personal preferences.
Why did these box recipes become so popular in the 1970s and 80s?
They offered busy families convenient, reliable meals that required minimal skill and used common pantry ingredients, perfect for the era’s changing family dynamics.
About the Author
