When Sarah Martinez called 911 last summer, flames were already shooting through her kitchen window. The mother of three watched helplessly from her driveway as precious minutes ticked by, waiting for help to arrive. What she didn’t know was that her local fire department was operating with just four firefighters on duty that night—barely enough to safely enter her burning home.
Sarah’s story isn’t unique in Canandaigua. It’s becoming the harsh reality of a fire department stretched dangerously thin, and now consultants are sounding the alarm that without major changes, the city’s emergency response system could face complete breakdown.
The wake-up call came Monday night when city officials received a blunt assessment that painted a troubling picture of the Canandaigua Fire Department’s current state.
Consultants Deliver Harsh Reality Check
The Finance Committee gathered February 9th to review updated findings from the Center for Public Safety Management’s comprehensive assessment of the city’s fire and EMS services. The results were sobering: Canandaigua fire staffing levels remain dangerously inadequate, leaving residents vulnerable and firefighters at risk.
The consulting firm didn’t mince words. They warned that the department remains “understaffed, overly dependent on mutual aid and vulnerable to systemwide EMS strain” without immediate intervention.
What makes this situation particularly concerning is how it affects real emergencies. When a structure fire breaks out, the current staffing model cannot assemble an effective response force without substantial help from neighboring departments.
“We’re essentially gambling with people’s lives every single day,” explained one department source familiar with the assessment. “Four firefighters split between two stations means we can barely handle a basic house fire, let alone multiple emergencies.”
The Numbers Don’t Lie: Current vs. Recommended Staffing
The stark reality of Canandaigua’s fire staffing crisis becomes clear when you look at the numbers. Here’s what consultants found:
| Current Situation | CPSM Recommendation | Gap |
|---|---|---|
| 4 firefighters per shift minimum | 7-9 firefighters per shift | 3-5 additional firefighters needed |
| Split between 2 stations | Better coordinated deployment | Operational restructuring required |
| Heavy mutual aid dependence | Self-sufficient initial response | 75% improvement in response capability |
The consultants identified several critical issues with current operations:
- Insufficient staffing to handle standard structure fires safely
- Over-reliance on mutual aid from neighboring departments
- Strained relationships with partner agencies limiting coordination
- Inadequate joint training opportunities
- Poor utilization of available resources like the VA Medical Center Fire Department
Perhaps most troubling is how mutual aid relationships have deteriorated over the decades. Several departments told consultants they feel underutilized when responding to Canandaigua calls and rarely participate in joint training exercises.
“The VA department can immediately provide three fully certified career firefighters, but they’re often just told to stand by instead of being integrated into actual fire suppression operations,” the assessment noted. “This represents a massive waste of readily available expertise.”
What This Means for Residents and Taxpayers
The staffing crisis affects everyone in Canandaigua, though many residents remain unaware of the risks they face daily. Response times suffer when departments must wait for mutual aid before entering burning buildings. Property damage increases when initial response forces are inadequate.
But the human cost could be devastating. Firefighter safety protocols require minimum crew sizes for interior operations. When departments are understaffed, they face impossible choices: risk firefighter lives with inadequate backup, or watch structures burn while waiting for help.
“Every call becomes a calculated risk,” explained a veteran firefighter who requested anonymity. “We know we’re putting ourselves and the public at risk, but what choice do we have? People are counting on us to show up.”
The financial implications are equally serious. Poor mutual aid relationships mean longer response times and higher insurance costs for residents. Emergency medical services face similar strain, potentially affecting ambulance availability during peak demand periods.
Consultants recommended a phased hiring plan over six to ten years to gradually increase minimum staffing levels. They also encouraged pursuing federal SAFER grants to help offset recruitment and training costs.
The assessment suggests several immediate improvements:
- Automatically dispatch VA Medical Center firefighters to structure fires
- Improve coordination with mutual aid partners through regular joint training
- Develop clear protocols for resource utilization during emergencies
- Create long-term staffing goals with realistic timelines
City officials now face difficult budget decisions. Increasing fire department staffing requires significant investment in salaries, benefits, and equipment. However, consultants warned that maintaining the status quo poses even greater risks to public safety and potential liability.
“The question isn’t whether we can afford to improve staffing,” one committee member noted. “It’s whether we can afford not to. The liability alone from a preventable tragedy would dwarf any staffing investments.”
The assessment also highlighted opportunities for improved efficiency through better coordination with existing resources. The VA Medical Center’s firefighters represent a valuable asset that could immediately strengthen response capabilities if properly integrated.
Moving forward, city leaders must balance fiscal responsibility with public safety imperatives. The consulting firm’s recommendations provide a roadmap, but implementation will require sustained political will and community support.
FAQs
How many firefighters does Canandaigua currently have on duty?
The city maintains a minimum of four firefighters per shift, split between two stations, which consultants say is dangerously inadequate.
What staffing level do experts recommend?
Consultants recommend increasing to at least seven firefighters per shift, with nine being the preferred level for safe and effective operations.
Why can’t mutual aid departments fill the gaps?
Relationships with partner agencies have been strained for decades, limiting coordination and training opportunities that would improve joint response capabilities.
How would increased staffing be funded?
The city could pursue federal SAFER grants and implement a phased hiring plan over six to ten years to spread costs while gradually improving coverage.
What immediate changes could improve response?
Automatically dispatching VA Medical Center firefighters to structure fires and improving coordination through regular joint training would provide immediate benefits.
What happens if nothing changes?
Consultants warn of continued operational risks, potential system-wide EMS strain, and vulnerability during emergencies that could result in preventable property damage or loss of life.
About the Author
